Would Steve Jobs React Differently to the iPhone XR?

Although Steve Jobs would have had no say in the latest iPhone, reflecting on the iPhone XR brings us back to the mind of a perfectionist to see how he might have reacted. Steve Jobs was known for his relentless pursuit of perfection, ensuring that every product Apple developed was innovative, user-friendly, and visually stunning. The iPhone XR, being a step down from the XS, placed numerous compromises that would likely have displeased him.

Perfectionism at Its Core

Steve Jobs was an advocate for quality, and the iPhone XR's inconsistencies would have been a point of contention. He believed in offering simple and straightforward options to users, but the iPhone XR is part of a lineage of seven different iPhones from Apple. With so many choices, Jobs might have seen the iPhone XR as a misstep, as simplification and ease of use were paramount in his design philosophy.

Design Philosophy

Jobs was deeply rooted in skeuomorphic design, where digital interfaces mimicked real-world objects and materials. From iOS 1 to iOS 6, his designs exuded charm and authenticity. However, the flat design of iOS 7 and beyond would have been a big departure from what Jobs was accustomed to and likely seen as an evolution he would have been reluctant to embrace. Additionally, the notch in the iPhone XR's display would have been anathema to his quest for perfection. The presence of a notch would have been akin to a blemish on a flawless product.

User Experience and Industrial Design

Another reason for disapproval would have been the user experience and industrial design. Jobs emphasized the importance of ergonomics and ease of use. With the iPhone XR being too large to comfortably use in one hand, this would have been a significant downside in his view. Despite the critique, it is possible that if Jobs were still alive, he would have eventually recognized the necessity for larger phones in the market. This would have been a pragmatic decision to maintain Apple's competitiveness in the face of market demands.

Commenting on X Tech

Jobs was no stranger to skepticism. He famously dismissed X tech before Apple embraced it, a perfect example being his initial stance on touchscreen technology before it became a staple in modern smartphones. Should he have seen the iPhone XR, he might have employed a similar communication style to that of Tim Cook, albeit with more fervor and conviction. Jobs' public statements, much like Tim Cook's, would have carried the weight of authority and wisdom, reflecting his strong beliefs and values.

The Return to Colors

Despite his adherence to design perfection, Jobs could be convinced to embrace certain elements of the iPhone XR. For instance, he appreciated vibrant colors with the iPod nano and mini. These devices were known for their striking visual appeal. While he may have had difficulty swallowing the notch entirely, Jobs' innovative nature could have led him to accept larger phones and vibrant designs as a necessary adaptation to the evolving market. He would have scrutinized these features but ultimately recognized their utility.

While Steve Jobs’ reaction to the iPhone XR is speculative, it underscores his deep commitment to quality and design excellence. His legacy lives on through Apple's continued pursuit of innovation and craftsmanship.