The Untold Story: Frodos Journey Without the Ring in Mordor

The Untold Story: Frodo's Journey Without the Ring in Mordor

Introduction

In J.R.R. Tolkien's The Lord of the Rings, the journey of Frodo Baggins to Mount Doom is one filled with peril and conflict. However, what if Frodo had taken off the Ring while in Mordor and kept the fact hidden from Samwise Gamgee and the rest of his companions? This scenario offers a fascinating exploration of how Frodo's mental state might have evolved, and the potential impact on the outcome of the war against Sauron.

Frodo's Journey and the Ring's Effect

From the outset, the Ring's influence on Frodo is clear. It corrupts even those who seem virtuous and pure-hearted. Gollum, driven by a gnawing desire for the Ring, ultimately becomes a reflection of its malevolent power. As Frodo carries the Ring, he begins to experience a creeping despair that threatens to consume him completely. The longer he holds the Ring, the more his soul is poisoned, until he is almost a shell of his former self.

The Lesser Option: Letting Go

Sam, on the other hand, embodies a rare strength of character. When he comes across the Ring, his first thought is to destroy it, which is why he remains steadfast and vigilant against the Ring's influence. Unlike Bilbo Baggins, who needed Gandalf's guidance, Sam possessed a natural resistance to the Ring. This quality of Sam suggests that those who are truly ready to destroy the Ring by any means necessary are the ones most likely to resist its corrupting influence.

Alternatives and Consequences

Scenario 1: Frodo Discards the Ring

Imagine Frodo removes the Ring and manages to conceal it from Sam. This act of decision may initially bring a sense of relief and clarity. While Frodo would no longer be as burdened by the Ring's influence, he might also fall into a temporary state of paranoia, questioning why he must keep such a secret. This secrecy could either drive him or those around him into a state of false security, leading to false assurance that the Ring is gone from them.

Scenario 2: Initiative and Issuance

The change in Frodo's condition could also result in a flurry of activity. He might try to secretly destroy the Ring at a more convenient time, hoping to avoid the attention of Sauron. However, this approach could also lead to a situation where the Ring mocks or torments him, driving him to distraction and possibly hallucinations. The Ring's malevolent voice might torment him, pushing him towards madness.

Scenario 3: The Descent into Madness

If Frodo discards the Ring and reveals it to no one, the psychological toll could be immense. The Ring's influence might transform him, but without the burden of secrecy, Frodo might face a different kind of mental breakdown. This could result in him becoming unpredictable and possibly even dangerous to his own companions. Additionally, his lack of awareness might leave him vulnerable to Gollum's manipulations, leading to potential capture by Sauron.

Sam's Role and the Ring's Influence

Sam's resolve to destroy the Ring is a critical element in the story. His natural resistance means he might face similar challenges, but he is less likely to be consumed by despair. However, if the Ring is removed and kept hidden, the Ring's voice could still corrupt Sam, driving him to madness. The Ring's power lies not just in possession but in the knowledge that its power exists, and Sam might be as drawn to it as any other mortal soul.

Concluding Thoughts

This hypothetical scenario provides a rich landscape for exploring the complex relationship between Frodo, Sam, and the Ring. It highlights the strength of character required to resist its influence and the potential consequences of hiding this strength. While the original story's outcome is definitive, this alternate path opens the door to fascinating discussions and interpretations.