The Truth Behind Faking an Extra Point in NFL: Understanding the Rules and Strategies

National Football League (NFL) teams have the option to attempt various scoring plays after a touchdown. One such strategy is the infamous 'fake extra point,' where a team might try to score in the guise of a regular extra point but end up running for a two-point conversion. Understanding the intricacies of these plays, their effectiveness, and the strategic considerations is crucial for both players and fans. This article explores the nuances of this fascinating aspect of NFL strategy.

1. Extra Point Attempt Rules

Following a touchdown, an NFL team has the choice between kicking the game's standard extra point (worth 1 point) or attempting a two-point conversion from the 2-yard line. This decision sets the stage for a potential 'fake extra point' scenario.

1.1. Kick the Extra Point

Attempting to kick the extra point is the more traditional and safer option. Teams can use a variety of kick attempts, such as a regular field goal (from the 15-yard line) or a special linebacker or player kicking a football over the crossbar. The primary goal here is to score 1 point to maintain momentum.

1.2. Two-Point Conversion

If a team opts for the two-point conversion, it attempts to score a touchdown from the 2-yard line. This play is riskier but potentially more rewarding, as a success here earns 2 points. The success rate for two-point conversions is generally lower, around 45-50%, due to the proximity to the end zone and the rigorous defense.

2. The Concept of a Fake Extra Point

A fake extra point involves a team lining up as though they intend to kick the extra point but then proceeding to run the ball into the end zone, effectively a two-point conversion. This strategy requires precise planning and execution to be successful. Here's how it works:

2.1. Planning and Setup

For a fake extra point to work, the offensive team must first announce at the line of scrimmage that they are going to attempt the extra point. Then, the defense is aware of the initial intention to kick. By playing a rush defense, defenders prepare for the possibility of a two-point conversion attempt.

2.2. Execution

The key to a successful fake extra point is deception. If the defense is expecting a run or pass from the 10-15 yard line, the offensive team must then execute a play to avoid detection and make it into the end zone. The offensive line must block effectively, and the quarterback or running back must make the play count to succeed.

3. Rare but Effective: Faking an Extra Point

While fake extra points are not common, they can be effective when executed correctly. Teams often use this strategy to tie the game, put themselves ahead, or add a psychological advantage. However, the success rate is low, and the risks are considerable.

3.1. Example of Success

Legendary coach Bill Walsh of the San Francisco 49ers used a fake extra point strategy successfully during a game. By misdirecting the defense and executing a precise play, Walsh's team reversed the game's course and secured a crucial victory.

3.2. Example of Failure

Notably, Matt Ryan, the quarterback of the Atlanta Falcons, faced a similar situation when lined up at the 16-yard line after a touchdown attempt. Despite the team's desperate need for a touchdown, Ryan's early verbal confirmation of the kick attempt and subsequent actual conversion attempt from the end zone led to a turnover on downs, with no points scored.

4. The Rulebook and Interpretations

The NFL rulebook allows for such creative play formations. According to Article 2, Rule 3 of the NFL rulebook, a team can line up and place the ball at any point within the 15-yard limits behind the line of scrimmage for a try kick. If the ball is run or passed into the end zone instead of being kicked, it results in a two-point conversion.

4.1. Oddity of the Rules

One peculiar aspect of the rules is the handling of a safety during a try kick. If a safety is scored, it results in a neutral point, adding no points to either team. This unique rule reflects the flexibility of NFL strategies but also highlights the need for precise play execution.

5. Strategic Considerations and Real-World Application

While the potential for a fake extra point appears promising, its effective use in real games is rare. The success of such a strategy depends on:

Effective communication and deception Strong execution from the offensive line and quarterbacks The defensive strategy and readiness The current score and time remaining in the game

It's essential for coaches to assess these factors and make informed decisions during the game. A poorly executed play can result in costly turnovers or a missed opportunity, whereas a successful attempt can dramatically shift the game's momentum.

Conclusion

Faking an extra point in NFL is both a challenge and an art. While the rules provide flexibility, the success rate is low due to the inherent risks. Understanding the mechanics, strategies, and various real-world examples can provide valuable insights for both fans and coaches. As football strategies continue to evolve, the potential for innovative plays like fake extra points will remain an intriguing aspect of the game.

Keywords

NFL Extra Point 2-Point Conversion Fake Extra Point in NFL