The Benefits and Losses of Being a United States Citizen Versus a U.S. National

Introduction

Many individuals have a deep appreciation for the privileges and responsibilities that come with being a U.S. citizen. However, the experience can be quite different when one moves out of the United States and resides in another country. This article explores the distinctive rights and nuances of being a citizen versus a national of the United States through the personal anecdotes and unique experiences shared by a North American expatriate. By delving into these aspects, we aim to highlight the cultural and societal differences that can shape one's daily life.

Understanding the Distinction

While the terms 'U.S. citizen' and 'U.S. national' are often used interchangeably, they carry distinct meanings. A U.S. citizen is someone who has the right to vote and hold certain government positions, whereas a U.S. national is anyone born or naturalized in the U.S. This distinction can lead to subtle but significant differences in daily life, particularly in terms of personal property rights and community relations.

Personal Experience in Sweden

The author recounted an anecdote of a newly arrived U.S. citizen living in a suburb of Stockholm, Sweden, who was confused about her rights and obligations regarding her neighbor. She had assumed that she had the right to request her neighbor to clean up his property. However, this assumption led to a cultural misunderstanding, as the Swedes viewed such behavior as a "cultural gaffe."

In the U.S., an individual has the freedom to arrange their property as they see fit without undue interference from neighbors. In contrast, the situation in Sweden reflects a more permissive attitude towards personal property, emphasizing respect for individual choice and independence. This highlights the cultural differences and the importance of understanding local norms when living in a foreign country.

Life in the U.S.

The author's life in the United States was characterized by a myriad of unique experiences that are not necessarily available in other countries. Some of these experiences included:

Free and accessible healthcare, which is a mixed blessing given the complexities and coverage debates. The availability of extensive public transportation networks, which can sometimes be overshadowed by the quality and efficiency of U.S. infrastructure. The cultural diversity and inclusion, which can be both enriching and frustrating depending on the personal perspective.

Life in Canada

Moving back to Canada has presented the author with a fresh set of challenges and restrictions, which are viewed through the lens of a former U.S. citizen:

The right to carry firearms has become nearly non-existent, a stark contrast to the U.S., where the Second Amendment brings a certain sense of security and responsibility. The lack of unique cultural experiences, such as the freedom to organize one's property as desired, which has now been somewhat restricted. The absence of some U.S.-specific legal and cultural norms, such as the anti-Semitic violence and racial discrimination experienced in parts of the U.S., now being more prevalent in some areas.

Conclusion

The transition from a U.S. citizen to a U.S. national involves both benefits and losses. While the freedom and rights enjoyed in the U.S. are recognized as essential, the experiences and privileges of life in other countries offer a different perspective. Understanding the cultural and societal norms of the new home is crucial for a smooth integration and appreciation of the local way of life. This article serves as a reminder that the definition of 'being American' can vary widely from person to person and from country to country.