Reflections on the Playing of 'My Old Kentucky Home' at the Kentucky Derby

For many, the Kentucky Derby is more than just a race or a spectacle; it is a deeply ingrained cultural and historical event that celebrates the unique heritage and spirit of Kentucky. From the horses that run in the Derby to the songs that are played, every aspect of the event is steeped in tradition. However, one particular song, 'My Old Kentucky Home,' has drawn mixed reactions and contemplations among enthusiasts and participants alike.

Why Kentucky Derby is About the Horses

Central to the essence of the Kentucky Derby is the sheer elegance and fortitude of the horses. The Derby is a celebration of the equine athletes, whose raw power and grace captivate audiences worldwide. As one derby enthusiast observes, 'To me, the Derby is about the horses, always has been and always will be.'

International Perspectives

Horses from around the globe contribute to the spectacle of the Kentucky Derby. The legendary Northern Dancer, bred in Canada, was a monumental influence, shaping the breed and setting a new standard for performance. Similarly, the California-bred Swaps, known for his incredible speed over a mile and his stamina for the 10 furlongs, demonstrated what it meant to be a champion. From Florida, we saw the mastery of Triple Crown winner Affirmed and the enduring breeding legacy of Unbridled, while in New Jersey, Regret followed a trail blazed by Northern Dancer. Texas, too, contributed with the iconic Assault.

Challenges with the Song 'My Old Kentucky Home'

A notable absence in the Derby's soundtrack is 'My Old Kentucky Home,' a song that rich with history but also marred by cultural significance. The sentiment associated with the song presents a complex layer in the celebration of heritage at the Derby. Advocates for the song argue that despite its historical context, it serves as a tribute to the land and the people who have shaped the Derby's legacy. However, many feel that the song carries too much negative baggage, with lyrics that evoke images of slavery and oppression.

Personal Preferences and Alternatives

For those seeking a more modern, sensitive approach, alternative songs like Dan Fogelberg's 'Run For The Roses' emerge as popular choices. 'Run For The Roses' is celebrated for its poignant capturing of the Derby's essence and its respectful treatment of the event's cultural and racial aspects. This song has resonated strongly with those who attend the Derby, including the speaker, who fondly remembers singing it with family members during the post-parade. Every year, the song evokes memories and emotions, bringing a nostalgic and sometimes tearful connection to the event.

Contemporary Perspectives

While some individuals may be troubled by the historical context of 'My Old Kentucky Home,' others like the current speaker find no issue with its use. They believe that holding the past accountable for contemporary attitudes is not a productive stance. Instead, they advocate for a future-focused outlook that respects the heritage while acknowledging the evolution of societal norms.

Whether one embraces 'My Old Kentucky Home' or chooses an alternative, the Kentucky Derby remains a deep part of the American cultural landscape, celebrated and mourned by those who have witnessed the event's grandeur. The Derby's rich history and evolving cultural context continue to shape its significance for generations to come.